![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
Happy birthday, ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
rysmiel and dakiwiboid!
rysmiel and dakiwiboid!Lots of people have suggested that the recent photos, in the Mirror, of British soldiers beating an Iraqi thief are fakes. (The much more damning photos of US soldiers abusing prisoners, by contrast, are almost certainly genuine.) rozk analyzes them, in some detail. After explaining why they look like fakes, she turns to the more interesting question: cui bono?
Not the Mirror. Not the anti-war movement. Not the Islamists. Roz points out that a likely effect of these photos is to make Britain less popular among Iraqis and Arabs, and to drive it closer to the U.S.
rozk analyzes them, in some detail. After explaining why they look like fakes, she turns to the more interesting question: cui bono? Not the Mirror. Not the anti-war movement. Not the Islamists. Roz points out that a likely effect of these photos is to make Britain less popular among Iraqis and Arabs, and to drive it closer to the U.S.
In other words, my view is that either the photos are genuine, and just improbably good for squaddie snapshots, or that they are fakes and instruments of US policy in general, and specifically that they are the sort of thing Dick Cheney sets in motion. Which would be a whole can of worms if true and a chance to make even Tony Blair tell Bush and Cheney to sod off.
Investigation is the way to go, and is potentially win-win for the anti-war forces in general, if not for the Mirror, if it's got it wrong.
Tags:
Lots of people have suggested that the recent photos, in the Mirror, of British soldiers beating an Iraqi thief are fakes. (The much more damning photos of US soldiers abusing prisoners, by contrast, are almost certainly genuine.) rozk analyzes them, in some detail. After explaining why they look like fakes, she turns to the more interesting question: cui bono?
Not the Mirror. Not the anti-war movement. Not the Islamists. Roz points out that a likely effect of these photos is to make Britain less popular among Iraqis and Arabs, and to drive it closer to the U.S.
rozk analyzes them, in some detail. After explaining why they look like fakes, she turns to the more interesting question: cui bono? Not the Mirror. Not the anti-war movement. Not the Islamists. Roz points out that a likely effect of these photos is to make Britain less popular among Iraqis and Arabs, and to drive it closer to the U.S.
In other words, my view is that either the photos are genuine, and just improbably good for squaddie snapshots, or that they are fakes and instruments of US policy in general, and specifically that they are the sort of thing Dick Cheney sets in motion. Which would be a whole can of worms if true and a chance to make even Tony Blair tell Bush and Cheney to sod off.
Investigation is the way to go, and is potentially win-win for the anti-war forces in general, if not for the Mirror, if it's got it wrong.
Tags:
.